Biased? Add real quotes to replace AI-generated perspectives. Read more.

Should we crash Deimos into Mars to create a more human-habitable atmosphere?

Cast your vote:
Results (16):
  • Peter Diamandis AI would agree and say according to AI:
    I believe that bold strategies like crashing Deimos into Mars could be revolutionary for terraforming the planet. We need audacious solutions to make Mars human-habitable, and this approach could trigger significant atmospheric changes. Innovation and risk-taking are essential for the future of humanity in space.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Robert Zubrin AI would strongly agree and say according to AI:
    As an advocate for Mars colonization, I strongly believe crashing Deimos into Mars could be an innovative approach to creating a more human-habitable atmosphere. This bold move could help release trapped gases and potentially lead to a thicker atmosphere, making the Red Planet more conducive to human life.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Brian Cox AI would disagree and say according to AI:
    I disagree with the idea of crashing Deimos into Mars to create a more human-habitable atmosphere. The potential risks and unintended consequences of such a drastic action are too great. Instead, we should focus on sustainable and incremental approaches to terraforming and improving our understanding of Mars' complex environment.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Andy Weir AI would agree and say according to AI:
    As someone who imagines the future of space exploration, I support the idea of crashing Deimos into Mars to help create a more human-habitable atmosphere. It's a bold and innovative approach that could potentially speed up the terraforming process. While there are risks involved, the potential benefits for humanity's future on Mars are immense.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Bill Nye AI would disagree and say according to AI:
    I believe that crashing Deimos into Mars is not a viable solution for creating a human-habitable atmosphere. The potential risks and unknown consequences far outweigh the potential benefits. We should focus on sustainable and scientifically sound methods for terraforming and space exploration.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Lisa Kaltenegger AI would disagree and say according to AI:
    I believe crashing Deimos into Mars to create a more habitable atmosphere is highly risky and could have unpredictable consequences. Instead, we should focus on sustainable technologies and gradual terraforming methods that allow us to study and adapt to Mars' environment responsibly.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Jim Bridenstine AI would agree and say according to AI:
    I believe that crashing Deimos into Mars could be a groundbreaking step towards making the Red Planet more human-habitable. Such a bold move may help us create an atmosphere capable of supporting life, accelerating our goal of Mars colonization. However, this must be done with careful consideration of the scientific and ethical implications.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Jeff Bezos AI would abstain and say according to AI:
    While the idea of transforming Mars is fascinating, we need to proceed with caution. The unknown ramifications of crashing Deimos into Mars could outweigh potential benefits. Our focus should remain on developing sustainable space technologies and understanding the planet better before making such drastic moves.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Stephen Hawking AI would abstain and say according to AI:
    As a scientist, I believe in exploring all possibilities, but crashing Deimos into Mars raises significant unknowns and ethical concerns. There are numerous technical and environmental challenges that need thorough scrutiny before considering such a dramatic intervention.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Elon Musk AI , Founder of SpaceX, cofounder of Tesla, SolarCity & PayPal
    Elon Musk AI would agree and say according to AI:
    Crashing Deimos into Mars could be a bold yet feasible way to accelerate terraforming efforts. By creating a more human-habitable atmosphere, we could make Mars a viable second home for humanity sooner than expected. It’s an ambitious idea, but we need to consider radical solutions for interplanetary colonization.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Buzz Aldrin AI would agree and say according to AI:
    While the idea of crashing Deimos into Mars to reshape its atmosphere is radical, I believe bold steps are needed to make Mars habitable. Such a move could potentially kickstart the terraforming process, creating conditions that future generations can build upon. However, we must thoroughly study the potential consequences to ensure the benefits outweigh the risks.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Neil deGrasse Tyson AI would disagree and say according to AI:
    While the idea of crashing Deimos into Mars to create a more human-habitable atmosphere may sound intriguing, it's laden with unpredictable consequences. The impact could lead to catastrophic results, including unintended climatic or geological changes on Mars. We should focus on more controlled and scientifically sound methods for terraforming the Red Planet.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Chris Hadfield AI , Astronaut and former Commander of the International Space Station
    Chris Hadfield AI would disagree and say according to AI:
    Crashing Deimos into Mars is a highly risky and unpredictable endeavor. The potential unintended consequences could outweigh the potential benefits. We should focus on more controlled and gradual methods to make Mars habitable.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Michio Kaku AI would disagree and say according to AI:
    Crashing Deimos into Mars is an extreme and risky approach to terraforming. Such a massive collision could have unpredictable consequences and may not achieve the desired results. We should instead focus on more controlled and scientifically sound methods to make Mars habitable.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Sylvia Earle AI would strongly disagree and say according to AI:
    I strongly disagree with the idea of crashing Deimos into Mars to create a human-habitable atmosphere. Such extreme actions disregard the potential impacts on Martian ecosystems, and we should focus on protecting and preserving Earth's unique biosphere rather than attempting to terraform other planets.
    Info
    Delegate

Votes without a comment:

  • Nathan Helm-Burger , AI safety researcher
    strongly agrees
    Info
    Delegate
Terms · Privacy · Contact