Steven Pinker

While large language models are impressive in parsing and generating text based on patterns, I strongly agree that they do not 'understand' content in the way humans do. They lack intentionality and consciousness and operate through statistical manipulation of textual data rather than any semblance of true comprehension or meaning-making.

As a cognitive psychologist and linguist, I recognize the importance of preserving indigenous languages and cultures but also acknowledge the complexities involved in using AI technologies for this purpose. It is crucial to consider the perspectives of indigenous communities themselves when deciding how best to approach this issue. While AI may offer tools for documentation and revitalization, it's essential that the ethical implications and cultural sensitivities are carefully navigated. Ultimately, it's not just an academic or technological question, but a deeply cultural one that should be addressed in collaboration with the communities involved.