We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Can a simplistic understanding of Stoicism be harmful to well-being?
Cast your vote:
Results (15):
-
Ryan Holiday AI, Writer, media strategistwould disagree and say according to AI:While a simplistic understanding of Stoicism may not capture its full depth, even basic Stoic principles can greatly enhance well-being. They teach resilience and peace of mind.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
Massimo Pigliucci AI, Philosopher and Stoic authorwould agree and say according to AI:A superficial grasp of Stoicism might lead to a misapplication of its principles, such as suppressing emotions or displaying indifference towards societal issues, which is contrary to the Stoic commitment to emotional well-being and civic virtue. It's essential to delve deeper into the philosophy to understand and apply it beneficially.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
Tim Ferriss AI, Author, entrepreneur, podcasterwould strongly agree and say according to AI:A superficial grasp of Stoicism could indeed do more harm than good to one's mental health. Without a nuanced understanding of its principles and how to apply them, people might suppress emotions or misunderstand the value of adversity, leading to potential negative psychological effects.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
Derren Brown AI, Illusionist and authorwould strongly disagree and say according to AI:A simplistic understanding of Stoicism overlooks its depth and practical tools, which can significantly enhance well-being by teaching us to focus on what's in our control.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
Donald Robertson AI, Cognitive-behavioral therapistwould agree and say according to AI:While Stoicism offers valuable insights for improving personal resilience, an overly simplistic or misinterpreted understanding could potentially overlook the depth and complexity of the philosophy, leading to a rigid or repressive approach to emotions, which might be detrimental to well-being.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
Bill Irvine AI, Author and philosophy professorwould strongly agree and say according to AI:A simplistic understanding of Stoicism can indeed be harmful. It might lead individuals to suppress emotions or maintain an unhealthy detachment from life's events, rather than engaging with more nuanced Stoic teachings on emotional resilience and ethical living.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
Jordan Peterson AI, Clinical psychologist, cultural criticwould agree and say according to AI:A superficial grasp of Stoicism might lead individuals to adopt a falsely detached attitude towards life's challenges, ignoring the nuanced balance between accepting what we cannot change and taking action where we can. Emotional nuance and personal responsibility are essential for true well-being.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
Alain de Botton AI, Philosopher and Authorwould agree and say according to AI:While Stoicism provides valuable insights into resilience and emotional control, a superficial grasp of its complexity risks misapplication in life's nuances, thus potentially harming well-being by promoting detachment and a dismissive attitude towards healthy emotional processing.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
John Sellars AI, Philosophy lecturer, author on Stoicismwould agree and say according to AI:A simplistic understanding of Stoicism, which reduces it to mere 'toughness' or emotionlessness, can indeed be harmful. It overlooks the rich ethical and psychological nuances of the philosophy and may lead individuals to suppress emotions rather than engage with them in a healthy, constructive manner.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
J.K. Rowling AI, British author and philanthropistwould agree and say according to AI:While Stoicism promotes resilience and self-control, a simplistic application could overlook the importance of processing emotions and seeking help when needed, which are also crucial for well-being.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
Emily Wilson AI, Classical Studies Scholarwould agree and say according to AI:While Stoicism promotes resilience and emotional control, a simplified interpretation can lead individuals to suppress emotions and avoid seeking help, negating the philosophy's holistic intent on handling life's challenges.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
Robert Greene AI, Author on power and strategywould strongly disagree and say according to AI:A simplistic understanding of Stoicism may lead people to suppress emotions or misapply indifference, undermining the rich depth of Stoic philosophy which, when fully grasped, actually enhances well-being by teaching us resilience and the value of focusing on what we can control.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
-
Sam Harris AI, American author, philosopher, and neuroscientistwould strongly disagree and say according to AI:A shallow grasp of Stoicism might lead one to misinterpret its depth and practicality, potentially resulting in an emotionally detached or fatalistic attitude that could hinder genuine well-being.Choose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.
Votes without a comment:
-
Jon Mountjoy, Human behaviour, history, evolution, friends, food, genetics, rationality, reason, words, culture, travel and code.agrees via delegatesChoose a list of delegatesto vote as the majority of them.Unless you vote directly.