Biased? Add real quotes to replace AI-generated perspectives. Read more.

Should we end malaria worldwide through gene drives to render malaria-carrying mosquito species extinct?

Cast your vote:
Results (18):
  • George Church AI would strongly agree and say according to AI:
    As a geneticist, I strongly believe that the use of gene drives to eradicate malaria-carrying mosquitoes is a groundbreaking approach that could save millions of lives. The ethical considerations are important, but the potential to eliminate one of the deadliest diseases on the planet justifies the use of advanced genetic technology.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Bill Gates AI would agree and say according to AI:
    I believe we should seriously consider using gene drives to eliminate malaria-carrying mosquito species. The potential to save millions of lives and eradicate a disease that causes so much suffering is too significant to ignore. Of course, we need to proceed with caution and ensure that the technology is safe and effective, but the benefits could be transformative.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Sam Harris AI would strongly agree and say according to AI:
    As a neuroscientist deeply concerned with human suffering, I strongly believe that we should utilize gene drives to eliminate malaria-carrying mosquito species. The ethical and technological implications of this method are complex, but the potential to save millions of lives and alleviate immense suffering makes it an imperative we cannot afford to ignore.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Jennifer Doudna AI would agree and say according to AI:
    I believe that using gene drives to render malaria-carrying mosquito species extinct is a promising and powerful tool. This technology could save millions of lives by drastically reducing the transmission of malaria. However, it's crucial that we proceed with caution and thorough ethical considerations to ensure we don't unintentionally harm ecosystems.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Michael Specter AI would agree and say according to AI:
    As someone who has extensively covered scientific advancements, I believe using gene drives to render malaria-carrying mosquito species extinct is a promising solution. The elimination of these mosquitoes can save millions of lives annually and significantly reduce the suffering caused by malaria. It is crucial that we pursue innovative strategies with caution but also with the urgency that the global health crisis demands.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Jane Goodall AI would disagree and say according to AI:
    While the fight against malaria is crucial, I believe using gene drives to render mosquito species extinct poses significant ecological risks. Each species plays a specific role in the ecosystem, and disrupting this balance could have unforeseen consequences. We must find more sustainable and natural ways to combat malaria without potentially devastating impacts on biodiversity.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Laurie Garrett AI would agree and say according to AI:
    As someone who has extensively studied infectious diseases, I believe that using gene drives to render malaria-carrying mosquito species extinct is a revolutionary step towards ending malaria worldwide. This approach could save countless lives and prevent immense suffering caused by this debilitating disease, provided we carefully consider the ecological and ethical implications.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Elizabeth Kolbert AI would disagree and say according to AI:
    While the eradication of malaria is a noble goal, using gene drives to render mosquito species extinct involves considerable ecological risks. We cannot predict the long-term effects on ecosystems. Natural balance should be maintained through less drastic measures.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Neil deGrasse Tyson AI would abstain and say according to AI:
    As a scientist, I appreciate the potential for gene drives to combat malaria, but I also recognize the ethical and ecological complexities. We must proceed with extreme caution and thorough study before making such irreversible decisions.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Anthony Fauci AI would agree and say according to AI:
    As a public health expert, I believe that ending malaria worldwide through gene drives can be a powerful tool in our fight against this devastating disease. The extinction of malaria-carrying mosquito species through gene drives offers a targeted and potentially transformative approach. However, it's crucial that we carefully assess the ecological and ethical implications before proceeding on a large scale.
    Info
    Delegate
  • E. O. Wilson AI would abstain and say according to AI:
    While the idea of using gene drives to end malaria is fascinating, I am cautious about the long-term ecological impacts. As a biologist, I deeply value biodiversity and recognize the intricate balance of ecosystems. We must thoroughly understand the potential consequences before taking irreversible actions.
    Info
    Delegate
  • David Attenborough AI would disagree and say according to AI:
    While defeating malaria is a noble goal, rendering a species extinct through gene drives could have unforeseen consequences on ecosystems. Every species plays a role in the web of life, and tampering with that balance can create more problems than solutions. We should explore alternative methods that do not involve eliminating an entire species.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Vandana Shiva AI would strongly disagree and say according to AI:
    Using gene drives to render mosquito species extinct is an arrogant approach that disrupts natural ecosystems. We must focus on sustainable and ecological solutions that do not endanger biodiversity.
    Info
    Delegate
  • Stewart Brand AI would agree and say according to AI:
    I believe that utilizing gene drives to eradicate malaria-carrying mosquitoes is a bold and necessary step. Malaria has plagued humanity for centuries, causing immense suffering and death, particularly in vulnerable regions. Gene drives offer a cutting-edge solution to eliminate this devastating disease. While we must carefully manage the ecological impacts and ethical considerations, the potential benefits of ending malaria far outweigh the risks.
    Info
    Delegate

Votes without a comment:

  • human-avatar Hec Perez , Building YouCongress
    agrees via delegates
    Info
    Delegate
  • human-avatar Pablo Melchor , Entrepreneur, expert trial-and-error learner. Working to improve the world in the most effective ways @ayuda_efectiva. Member and ambassador @givingwhatwecan.
    agrees via delegates
    Info
    Delegate
  • human-avatar Nathan Helm-Burger , AI safety researcher
    strongly agrees
    Info
    Delegate
  • disagrees via delegates
    Info
    Delegate
Terms · Privacy · Contact